How to Survive a Rental Bidding War

Q: I lately attended an open property for a rental in Park Slope, Brooklyn, where by the broker permit applicants know in advance, through e mail and in individual, that he would be accepting finest and ultimate presents on rent and commission. This was no luxurious condominium the making wasn’t new, nor did it have any facilities. I available the detailed rate: $6,000 a month, with a 15 percent commission. He responded that he had presently acquired provides for $6,800 and that I would have to offer far more to be considered. How really should renters react to these methods?

A: An apartment is really worth as much as a individual is inclined to spend for it. In this rental sector, with a dearth of listings and intense demand from customers, several prospective renters seem eager to shell out rather a little bit. In May possibly, 18 percent of all New York Town rental listings finished up in bidding wars, according to a Douglas Elliman report — a development affecting apartments from the bottom of the industry to the top rated. Very long strains for open properties are commonplace. TikTok is whole of movies posted by fight-weary apartment hunters lamenting their great deal.

In New York, bidding wars are authorized for market place-charge apartments. Having said that, landlords are not able to acknowledge a number of months’ of rent up front. Broker costs are unregulated, also, and are now the accountability of the tenant, following a respite earlier in the pandemic when landlords picked up the price. While a cost of 15 percent of the yearly lease has turn into an marketplace conventional, there is very little blocking a broker from demanding more. Keyan Sanai, a salesperson for Douglas Elliman, stated he had listened to of brokers fetching commissions of 18 or 20 per cent. “Right now, brokers have as well a great deal ability,” he reported.


To locate an apartment in this industry, initial choose on your greatest budget. Then look at residences below that amount there is a very good prospect you may want to pad your provide to the landlord, the broker or equally. How considerably will you will need to offer? Sad to say, there is no magic amount. Brokers are reporting residences renting for a several hundred bucks to a few thousand more than the asking lease. The remedy will depend on how determined the other bidders have turn out to be.

Exhibit up organized to make an offer you. Have all your paperwork in get, which includes your spend stubs, bank statements, proof of employment and letters of advice. If you will be working with a guarantor, make confident you have that person’s economic information ready, way too. And display up early.

“It’s initially come very first served,” reported Nicole Hechter, an affiliate broker with Corcoran. “Put your finest foot forward. There will be a bidding war. It will go up in price.”

Whatsoever rent you concur to pay back, remember that your potential lease boosts will be based mostly on that value, so be cognizant of your present-day and lengthy-phrase spending budget just before you sign the lease.

For weekly e mail updates on residential authentic estate news, sign up here. Follow us on Twitter: @nytrealestate.